Sessie: Structurele evaluatie voor adaptief beleid banner flags EU.tif Sessie: Structurele evaluatie voor adaptief beleid Bernard Steunenberg |Institute of Public Administration
Vormen van evaluatieonderzoek After years of implementation Static and limited learning: changes in goals Ex post evaluations (‘accountability’) Impact assessments (European Commission) Estimating policy effects Ex ante evaluations (‘uncertainty’) Process: during implementation At regular intervals (1-2 years), but not instant Ex durante evaluations (‘monitoring’) Dynamic: ‘Real life’ information on policy effects in dashboards Continuous learning and adaptation Evaluation based on feedback loops
Adaptieve beleidsvorming Learning Incremental change Classical/quasi experimental designs Other methods Data Data collection Linking datasets From data to information (validity) Policy evaluations Real-time feedback Ex durante evaluations Sometimes ex-post or ex-ante Adaptive policymaking Data sharing and use Data ownership Visualisations
Adaptiviteit als methode Main features ‘real-time’ indicators Short feedback-loops on interventions and results (Experimentation) Assessment Incremental changes Continuous learning during implementation Limitations Learning depends on discretion No ‘paradigm’ shifts
Onze drie sprekers Enno Ebels Jan de Ridder Maarten van Kooij (Vz concernoverleg Onderzoek Gemeente Den Haag) Evalueren in de gemeentelijke praktijk Jan de Ridder (Directeur Rekenkamer Amsterdam) Quasi-experimentele designs en armoedebestrijding Maarten van Kooij (Strategisch adviseur Gemeente Rotterdam) Bridge: experimenten in Rotterdam Zuid