| faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research review on the process of matching decision making Kirti Zeijlmans Hans Grietens University.

Presentatie over: "| faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research review on the process of matching decision making Kirti Zeijlmans Hans Grietens University."— Transcript van de presentatie:

1 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research review on the process of matching decision making Kirti Zeijlmans Hans Grietens University of Groningen

2 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Definition The process of deciding on the best fit of the child characteristics with the (available) foster family characteristics with as criterion the rate of success of the placement (based on Strijker & Zandberg, 2001; Van Dam, Nordkamp & Robbroeckx, 2000) 2

3 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Foster care process Selection of children: -Right type of intervention (Van Oijen, 2010; Van Dam, Nordkamp & Robbroeckx, 2000; Ter Meulen, Vinke, De Baat & Spoelstra, 2014) Selection of families: - Recruitment (Waterhouse & Brocklesby, 2001) -Training and selection (Van Oijen, 2010; Van Dam, Nordkamp & Robbroeckx, 2000; Ter Meulen, Vinke, De Baat & Spoelstra, 2014) Matching: - Enough information (Ryburn, 1991) - Time (Waterhouse & Brocklesby, 2001) 3 Matching Selection of children Selection of families Placement

4 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research on interaction ›Cultural matching (Brown, George, Sintzel & Arnault, 2009; Cousins, 2011; Flynn, 2000) ›Sibling placement (Washington, 2007) ›Attachment (Walker, 2008) 4

5 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Attachment Walker (2008) and Ter Meulen, Vinke, De Baat & Spoelstra (2014) 5 Family Child SecureAvoidantAmbivalentDisorganized Secure+++ Avoidant++ Ambivalent++ Disorganized+

6 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research on interaction ›Cultural matching (Brown, George, Sintzel & Arnault, 2009; Cousins, 2011; Flynn, 2000) ›Sibling placement (Washington, 2007) ›Attachment (Walker, 2008) ›Needs of the child (Street & Davies, 1999; Veevers, 1991) ›Behavior (Strijker & Zandberg, 2001; Doelling & Johnson, 1990) 6

7 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Behavior Source: Strijker & Zandberg, 2001 7 Type of childType of family Withdrawn-social problems Agressive-delinquentStructured Attention and social problems Fragile-structured NormalConforming Involved

8 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Research on interaction ›Cultural matching (Brown, George, Sintzel & Arnault, 2009; Cousins, 2011; Flynn, 2000) ›Sibling placement (Washington, 2007) ›Attachment (Walker, 2008) ›Needs of the child (Street & Davies, 1999; Veevers, 1991) ›Behavior (Strijker & Zandberg, 2001; Doelling & Johnson, 1990) 8

9 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Ways of matching ›Matching to find a fitting family ›Matching to find a fitting child ›Availability matching 9

10 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Matching differences Laakso & Pösö, 2014; De Baat, Spoelstra, Ter Meulen & Binke, 2014 10 Country Organization Matcher

11 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Conclusion ›Matching is:  Unpredictable  Complex  Uncertain  Subjective But: it is important and deserves our attention! 11

12 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Thank you Kirti Zeijlmans – k.zeijlmans@rug.nlk.zeijlmans@rug.nl Hans Grietens – h.grietens@rug.nlh.grietens@rug.nl

13 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Literature (1) ›Baat, M. de, Spoelstra, J., Ter Meulen, G., Stoltenborgh, M., & Vinke, A. (2014). Matching van langdurig uithuisgeplaatste jeugdigen aan een pleeggezin of gezinshuis. Hoe werkt het in de praktijk? ADOC, Nederlands Jeugdinstituut & Gezinspiratieplein. ›Brown, J.D., George, N., Sintzel, J. & Arnault, D. (2009). Benefits of cultural matching in foster care. Children and Youth Services Review, 31, 1019-1024. ›Cousins, J. (2003). Are we missing the match?: Rethinking adopter assessment and child profiling. Adoption & Fostering, 27, 7-18. ›Cousins, J. (2011). Making matches. London: BAAF. ›Dam, W. van, Nordkamp, S., & Robbroeckx, L. (2000). Passen en meten in de pleegzorg. Plaatsingsmethodiek nader onderzocht. Amsterdam: SWP ›Doelling, J. L., & Johnson, J. H. (1990). Predicting success in foster placement: The contribution of parent-child temperament characteristics. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 60(4), 585-593. doi:10.1037/h0079210 ›Flynn, R. (2000). Black carers for white children: shifting the ‘same-race’ placement debate. Adoption & Fostering, 24, 47-52. ›Meulen, G. ter, Vinke, A., Baat, M. de & Spoelstra, J. (2014). Matching van langdurig uithuisgeplaatste jeugdigen aan een pleeggezin of gezinshuis. Een overzicht uit de literatuur. ADOC, Nederlands Jeugdinstituut & Gezinspiratieplein. ›Maeyer, S. de, Vanderfaeillie, J., Van Holen, F., Vanschoonlandt, F., & Leconte, L. (2013). De vragenlijst beoordeling pleegzorgsituaties (VBPS): Een instrument ter ondersteuning van het matchingproces in pleegzorg, een pilootonderzoek. Orthopedagogiek: Onderzoek En Praktijk, 52(1), 17-32. 13

14 | faculty of behavioural and social sciences 08-04-2015 Literature (2) ›Oijen, S. van (2010). Resultaat van pleegzorgplaatsingen: Een onderzoek naar breakdown en de ontwikkeling van adolescente pleegkinderen bij langdurige pleegzorgplaatsingen. University of Groningen ›Pösö, T., & Laakso, R. (2014). Matching children and substitute homes: some theoretical and empirical notions. Child and Family Social Work, Advance online publication. doi10.1111/cfs.12144 ›Ryburn, M. (1991). The myth of assessment. Adoption & Fostering, 15(1), 20-27. doi:10.1177/030857599101500106 ›Strijker, J., & Zandberg, T. (2001). Matching in de pleegzorg: Hulpvraag versus hulpaanbod. Amsterdam: SWP. ›Veevers, H.M. (1991). Which child, which family? Adoption & Fostering, 15, 42-46. ›Walker J. (2008). The Use of Attachment Theory in Adoption and Fostering. Adoption & Fostering, 32, 49-57. ›Washington, K. (2007). Research review: Sibling placement in foster care: A review of the evidence. Child & Family Social Work, 12(4), 426-433. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2206.2006.00467.x ›Waterhouse, S. & Brocklesby, E. (2001). Placement choice in temporary foster care. A research study. Adoption & Fostering, 25(3), 39-46. 14