The well-being of incarcerated mothers in the Netherlands

Presentatie over: "The well-being of incarcerated mothers in the Netherlands"— Transcript van de presentatie:

1 The well-being of incarcerated mothers in the Netherlands
Anne-Marie Slotboom & Willemijn van Kalmthout VU University Amsterdam 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

2 Prison studies In debate about punishment two aspects hardly mentioned: Experiences of those confronted with criminal justice system Few studies about women’s experiences 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

3 Dallas county jail for women
12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

4 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

5 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

6 Differences between imprisoned men and women
Women more often sexually abused More drug use Lower educated More suicide attempts More psychological and physical health complaints Parenting 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

7 Incarcerated mothers Few opportunities for contact with children
Lost their parenting role No control about parenting process Anxiety, depression, less self-confidence En wat bij moeders? 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

8 Research question What are the effects of motherhood on the psychological well-being of incarcerated mothers? 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

9 Research methods Survey “International Study on Women’s Imprisonment” (ISWI) 114 questions e.g. accommodation, (mental) health, work/education, relations with the outside Interview 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

10 Characteristics sample
Percentages (N=251) Nationality Dutch Other 76% 24% Age < 25 25-34 35-45 >45 19% 35% 27% Marital status Married/living together Divorced Single 20% 53% Children Children < 18 65% Genomineerde NVK scripties over Bejaarde Boeven - Ter Peel vrouw van 62, diabetes, moeilijk traplopen 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

11 Characteristics sample Percentages (N=251)
Educational level Low Medium High 53% 32% 15% Job before detention 76% Imprisoned before 35% Crime Violent Property Drugs Other 20% 29% 31% 68% Sentenced Sentence length < 7 months 7-24 months 25-48 months > 49 months 24% 38% 19% 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

12 Results 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

13 Results 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

14 Psychological complaints mothers-non mothers
Statement M SD Depression I often feel depressed 2.79 1.07 2.68 .84*** I often feel tensed 2.97 1.06 2.85 .90** I worry a lot 3.10 1.08 3.00 .97* Irritability I am often so enraged that I could break something 1.87 1.16 1.88 1.03* Self-harm I feel as though I cannot bear another day here 2.71 1.12 2.33 1.01** * p < .10 ** p < .05. *** p < .01 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

15 Backward multiple regression analysis for self harm
Β SE F t R² P Self harm (n = 200) 17.6 .42 .000 Repressed by staff .17 .03 2.62 .010 Respected by staff -.13 -2.06 .041 Problems in prison .04 2.86 .005 Contact with family .08 -2.24 .026 Children < 18 .28 .13 4.62 Previous treatment for mental problems 3.07 .002 Native language .33 -2.25 Being in prison before -.19 -3.19 Voor verschillend klachten, regressies gedraaid, alleen bij kans op zelfverwonding speelt ook moeder zijn een rol. 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

16 Mother –child questionnaire (n=129)
Children < 18 91% Child resides with father 29% grandparents 21% other relatives 15% foster care 14% Contact with child 75% Child visits mothers 45% (every two weeks) 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

17 Relation between psychological wellbeing and contact with child
Statement Contact with child I am often so enraged I could break something .29** I sometimes consider harming myself .32** I have deliberately harmed myself p < .05. * p < .01** 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

18 Relation between psychological wellbeing and number of visits child
Statement Number of visits child I sometimes consider harming myself -.43** I feel as though the situation has me at its mercy -.38* p < .05. * p < .01** 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

19 Relation between psychological wellbeing and relationship with child
Statement Relationship with child I am often so enraged that I could break something .29* I am often irritated and angry p < .05. * p < .01** 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008

20 Conclusions Women a lot of psychological problems
Mothers more symptoms than non-mothers Due to problems in contact with child Mothers very positive about relationship with child –cognitive dissonance Meer klachten dan mannen – psychologische/psychiatrische zorg gelijk aan mannen – problemen reintegratie, problemen in hernemen van opvoedingsrol Ondanks niet geheel eenduidige resultaten lit – niet veel onderzoek overigens – moeders op een aantal domeinen meer klachten, vooral gerelateerd aan mogelijkheden kind te zien – Moeders desondanks erg positief over relatie met kind – melden dat relatie, koud, afstandelijk, problematisch is, onaangename gevoelens, emoties. Welbevinden van vrouwen afhankelijk van relationele rol, in staat relaties te onderhouden. Nadelen onderzoek – beperkt aan tal personen, invullen IES – traumatische ervaringen, te moeilijk, gaat je niets aan, ook afdelingen extra zorg meenemen, sociale wenselijkheidsschaal. Meer aandacht gezondheid, meer aandacht relatie moeder-kind. – Maar – niet elke ouder in staat ouderrol op zich te nemen “goed dat mijn moeder vast zit, ik ben volwassene, zij kind” “moeder moet daar blijven ze heeft iemand vermoord, geld, drugs”. 12/24/2018 Edinburgh ESC 2008